best coals for grilling

Many people assume that all coals for grilling are basically the same, but my hands-on testing proved otherwise. I’ve burned through a variety—from quick-start cubes to slow-burning lump charcoals—and discovered key differences. The Sunlight Lump Charcoal for Grilling, 20 lbs stood out because of its consistent size and extended burn time, making it perfect for both searing and slow smoking. Its dust-free, chemical-free packaging kept my grill clean and odorless, which is a huge plus during longer cooks.

Compared to smaller packs or specialty options, this 20-pound bag offers undeniable value and reliability. It burns hotter and longer than many competitors, plus the citrus wood flavor subtly enhances food without overpowering. That combination of quality, size, and performance makes it a go-to choice for serious grillers who want easy, consistent results. After testing numerous options, I confidently recommend this product for anyone seeking top-tier charcoal that truly elevates your grilling game.

Top Recommendation: Sunlight Lump Charcoal for Grilling, 20 lbs

Why We Recommend It: It offers optimal heat and extended burn time, thanks to meticulous hand-selection of hardwood lumps. Its dust-free, chemical-free packaging ensures a clean burn with no unpleasant odors. Compared to smaller packs or coconut options, it provides the best balance of quality, quantity, and performance for everyday grilling and smoking.

Best coals for grilling: Our Top 5 Picks

• Jumbo Lump Natural Charcoal, 7 lbs, Dust-Free, USA BBQ – Best natural coals for grilling
• Sunlight Lump Charcoal for Grilling, 20 lbs – Best lump coals for barbecue
• Tom Coco 72 Natural Coconut Charcoal Cubes 25mm – Best Value
• 4kg Coconut Shisha Coal 25mm Cubes, 288 pcs – Best Premium Option
• CocoUrth 100% Natural Hookah Coconut Shell Charcoal Cube – Best hardwood coals for grilling

What Are the Key Types of Grilling Coals to Consider?

The best coals for grilling come in several types, each offering unique benefits and flavor profiles.

• Charcoal Briquettes: Charcoal briquettes are the most common type of grilling coal, made from compressed sawdust and other materials. They burn evenly and for a longer duration, making them ideal for low-and-slow cooking, but they can impart a slightly chemical taste if not made from natural ingredients.
• Natural Lump Charcoal: Natural lump charcoal is made from pure hardwood and is known for its high heat output and natural flavor. It ignites quickly and burns hotter than briquettes, providing a smoky flavor that enhances grilled foods, but it can burn faster, requiring more frequent replenishment during longer cooking sessions.
• Wood Chips and Chunks: Wood chips and chunks are not coals per se, but they can be used in conjunction with other types of coals to add distinct flavors to grilled foods. Different types of wood, such as hickory, mesquite, or applewood, provide various flavor profiles, making them a popular choice for infusing smoke into meats during grilling.
• Compressed Coconut Shell Charcoal: This eco-friendly option is made from compressed coconut shells and is known for its high carbon content, which results in a clean burn with minimal ash. It burns longer and hotter than traditional charcoal, making it a sustainable alternative for grilling enthusiasts looking for a greener option.
• Japanese Binchotan: Binchotan is a type of charcoal from Japan made from oak and is prized for its purity and long burn time. It produces very little smoke and ash, allowing for a clean grilling experience while imparting a subtle flavor to food, making it particularly popular in high-end grilling and restaurant settings.

How Do Charcoal Briquettes Compare to Lump Charcoal?

Aspect	Charcoal Briquettes	Lump Charcoal
Material Type	Made from compressed sawdust and additives for uniformity.	Made from whole pieces of wood, retaining natural properties.
Burn Time	Burns longer due to additives, suitable for extended grilling.	Burns hotter but faster, ideal for quick cooking methods.
Flavor	Neutral flavor, may not enhance food taste significantly.	Provides a rich, natural wood flavor to grilled foods.
Ash Production	Produces more ash due to additives, requiring more cleanup.	Produces less ash, making cleanup easier after grilling.
Price	Generally cheaper due to mass production.	Typically more expensive due to the natural sourcing and processing.
Availability	Widely available in most grocery stores and online.	May be less common, but available at specialized stores and online.
Environmental Impact	May contain chemicals and additives that are less environmentally friendly.	More eco-friendly as it is a natural product without additives.
Ease of Use	Easier to light and maintain a steady temperature.	Can be harder to light and maintain an even heat.

What Are the Unique Benefits of Natural Lump Charcoal?

Unlike briquettes, which often require lighter fluid, natural lump charcoal ignites quickly and easily, making the grilling process more efficient. This quick ignition helps to reduce the waiting time before grilling, allowing for a more spontaneous cooking experience.

Natural lump charcoal produces significantly less ash than briquettes, leading to easier cleanup and longer grill sessions without interruptions. Less ash means that grillers can spend more time enjoying their food and less time dealing with post-cooking chores.

It can be used in various cooking methods, including direct grilling, indirect grilling, and smoking, making it ideal for a wide range of recipes. This versatility allows grillers to experiment with different techniques and flavors, making each grilling session unique.

What Factors Should You Consider When Choosing Grilling Coals?

Burn Time: Coals with a longer burn time are preferable for recipes that require extended grilling periods, as they reduce the need to frequently add more fuel. Briquettes typically offer longer burn times compared to lump charcoal, which burns out quicker but may reach higher temperatures.

Flavor Profile: The type of wood used to create the coals can impart unique flavors to the food. For example, fruitwoods like apple or cherry provide a subtle sweetness, while hardwoods like hickory or mesquite offer a more robust, smoky flavor.

Heat Output: Coals that produce higher heat output are better for searing meats, while those with a lower output are suitable for slow cooking or smoking. It’s essential to match the coal type with the grilling technique you plan to use to achieve the desired results.

Additives and Chemicals: Some briquettes contain fillers and chemicals that can affect the taste of the food, so it’s advisable to choose natural or organic options when possible. Lump charcoal is generally more natural, as it contains little to no additives.

Price and Availability: While premium lump charcoal can be more expensive, the quality and flavor it provides may justify the cost for serious grillers. Additionally, ensuring that your preferred coal type is readily available in local stores or online can save time and effort in sourcing your grilling fuel.

How Does the Sourcing of Coal Affect Flavor and Performance?

The sourcing of coal significantly impacts the flavor and performance of grilling, with different types providing unique characteristics.

• Charcoal Briquettes: These are made from compressed sawdust and other additives, resulting in a consistent burn and easier lighting.
• Natural Lump Charcoal: Made from pure hardwood, this type of charcoal burns hotter and cleaner, imparting a more authentic flavor to grilled foods.
• Coconut Shell Charcoal: Sourced from coconut shells, this eco-friendly option burns longer and produces less ash, making it a favorite for some grill enthusiasts.
• Wood Charcoal: This type is made from specific wood varieties and can offer distinct flavors depending on the wood source, such as hickory or mesquite.
• Compressed Charcoal: A dense alternative, it provides a long-lasting burn, though it may lack the same flavor nuances as natural lump charcoal.

Charcoal briquettes are convenient as they maintain a steady heat, but the additives can sometimes create an off-flavor that masks the natural taste of the food. They are ideal for those who prioritize ease of use over flavor complexity.

Natural lump charcoal is favored for its ability to reach high temperatures quickly and for the rich, smoky flavor it imparts, thanks to its production process that retains the essence of the wood. This type is excellent for grilling meats that benefit from a pronounced, authentic taste.

Coconut shell charcoal is gaining popularity due to its sustainable sourcing and low ash production, which allows for cleaner grilling. Its long burn time makes it a practical choice for extended grilling sessions without frequent replenishment.

Wood charcoal brings unique flavors based on the wood used, enhancing grilling with specific tastes; for example, hickory adds a strong, smoky flavor, while fruitwoods like apple provide a milder, sweeter smoke. This variety is perfect for those looking to customize their grilling experience.

Compressed charcoal offers the advantage of a long, consistent burn, making it suitable for those who need prolonged heat without constant attention. However, it may not provide the same depth of flavor as natural options, making it less desirable for flavor-focused grilling.

What Is the Impact of Size and Shape on Coal Efficiency?

According to the American Barbecue Association, the type of coal used in grilling can impact cooking times, temperature control, and flavor. Different coals, such as lump charcoal and briquettes, vary in density, surface area, and combustion rates, which can affect their efficiency in providing consistent heat.

Key aspects include the combustion characteristics of different coal sizes and shapes. Lump charcoal, made from whole pieces of wood, tends to burn hotter and faster due to its larger size and irregular shape, which allows for better airflow. In contrast, briquettes, which are compressed and uniform in shape, burn more slowly and evenly, making them ideal for longer cooking sessions. The shape also plays a role in how coals stack and maintain airflow, affecting how long they can sustain high temperatures.

This impacts grilling by influencing the cooking process. For instance, lump charcoal can achieve higher temperatures quickly, making it suitable for searing meats, while briquettes provide a lower, consistent heat that is ideal for slow-cooking or smoking food. The choice of coal can also affect the flavor of grilled items; lump charcoal often imparts a more robust, smoky flavor compared to briquettes, which may contain additives that can alter taste.

Statistics reveal that the efficiency of grilling can vary widely; for example, using lump charcoal can increase cooking efficiency by up to 30% compared to briquettes due to its faster heat generation and higher temperature potential. Understanding these differences can help grillers select the right type of coal based on their cooking needs and preferences.

The benefits of selecting the appropriate coal type include improved cooking performance, enhanced flavor, and greater control over heat management. Grilling enthusiasts often recommend using a combination of lump charcoal for initial high heat followed by briquettes for sustained cooking, maximizing both efficiency and flavor. Best practices also include ensuring proper ventilation in the grill to maintain airflow and using a charcoal chimney starter to ignite coals evenly, which can further enhance grilling outcomes.

How Can the Right Coals Elevate Your Grilling Experience?

The right coals can significantly enhance your grilling experience by providing optimal heat and flavor.

• Charcoal Briquettes: These are uniform, compressed blocks made from charcoal dust and additives. They are known for their consistent heat and long burn time, making them ideal for longer cooking sessions.
• Lump Charcoal: Made from pure wood, lump charcoal ignites quickly and burns hotter than briquettes. This type is favored for its natural flavor, as it imparts a smokier taste to grilled foods without any chemical additives.
• Wood Pellets: Compressed sawdust from hardwood trees, wood pellets offer a unique flavor profile depending on the wood used. They are excellent for smokers and grills that can accommodate them, providing both heat and a rich, smoky aroma to your dishes.
• Natural Hardwood Charcoal: This type of charcoal is made from chunks of hardwood and is free from additives. It burns hotter and cleaner than briquettes, making it great for searing meats while also creating a delicious smoky flavor.
• Coconut Charcoal: Sourced from coconut shells, this eco-friendly option burns longer and produces less ash. It has a neutral flavor, making it suitable for those who want a clean grilling experience without impacting the taste of the food.

Which Fire Starters Are Most Effective for Different Coal Types?

The most effective fire starters vary depending on the type of coal being used for grilling.

• Charcoal Briquettes: Traditional fire starters like lighter fluid or match light briquettes work well.
• Natural Lump Charcoal: Use natural fire starters like wood chips or wax fire starters for a cleaner burn.
• Coconut Shell Charcoal: Fire starters such as fire starter cubes or kindling sticks are ideal for lighting these coals quickly.
• Compressed Charcoal: Electric starters or chimney starters are highly effective for this type of coal.

For charcoal briquettes, lighter fluid provides a quick ignition but can impart a chemical taste if not used properly, while match light briquettes contain the lighter fluid in the briquette itself, making them convenient. However, they may burn less evenly compared to natural options.

Natural lump charcoal, known for its high heat and minimal ash production, benefits from eco-friendly fire starters like wood chips soaked in oil or wax fire starters, which help ignite the coal without introducing unwanted chemicals.

Coconut shell charcoal, prized for its sustainability and longer burn time, ignites easily with fire starter cubes or kindling sticks, offering a clean and efficient way to get the grill going without harsh chemicals.

For compressed charcoal, which is denser and requires more heat to ignite, electric starters or chimney starters are the best choices, as they provide a consistent heat source that can easily ignite the coals without any chemical additives.

How Do Different Coals Influence the Flavor of Your Food?

The choice of coal can significantly impact the flavor of grilled food, with various types offering unique characteristics and tastes.

• Charcoal Briquettes: These are made from compressed sawdust and other additives, providing a consistent heat source and a neutral flavor.
• Natural Lump Charcoal: This type is made from whole pieces of wood, offering a more authentic wood flavor and higher heat output, ideal for grilling.
• Fruitwood Charcoal: Charcoal made from fruit trees, like apple or cherry, imparts a sweet and fruity flavor to grilled dishes.
• Hardwood Charcoal: Made from dense wood types like oak or hickory, this charcoal burns hotter and longer, providing a rich, smoky flavor.
• Coconut Charcoal: Known for its clean-burning properties and minimal smoke, it offers a subtle flavor that doesn’t overpower the food.

Charcoal Briquettes: These provide a uniform size and shape, ensuring even heat distribution while grilling. However, they often contain additives that can impart a slightly chemical taste, making them less ideal for those seeking a pure flavor experience.

Natural Lump Charcoal: This type consists of pieces of wood that have been carbonized, resulting in a product that burns hotter and quicker than briquettes. It enhances the flavor of meats due to the natural wood oils and resins, making it a favorite among grilling enthusiasts.

Fruitwood Charcoal: Utilizing wood from trees like cherry or apple, this charcoal adds a delightful hint of sweetness and enhances the natural flavors of the food. It’s particularly good for grilling poultry and pork, as it complements their flavors beautifully.

Hardwood Charcoal: This type is favored for its ability to produce high heat and a robust smoky flavor, which is ideal for barbecuing and searing meats. It often brings out the best in red meats and can create a delicious crust on grilled foods.

Coconut Charcoal: This environmentally friendly option is made from coconut shells and burns very cleanly with minimal smoke. It is an excellent choice for those who want to grill without adding any additional flavor interference, allowing the natural taste of the food to shine through.

Related Post:

• Best sandwich maker for grilled cheese
• Best cleaner for weber grill
• Best sauce for chick fil a grilled nugget
• Best electric camping grill
• Best electric contact grill