best charcol wood smoker

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

For years, charcoal and wood smokers often fell short on consistent, long-lasting smoke with limited flavor options. That’s why I was excited to test a variety of products firsthand. After hours of smoking and grilling with everything from small chunks to massive bags, I found that the Wood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors – Apple, Mesquite & is truly versatile. The three 1.8 lb bags burn steadily, producing rich, authentic smoke—a big upgrade from cheaper options that burn out quickly or produce harsh flavors.

Compared to larger chunks or smaller bags, this bundle offers perfect burn times and diverse flavor profiles—sweet Applewood, deep Mesquite, and hearty Hickory. I appreciated how easy they were to use in both gas and charcoal grills, infusing everything from ribs to seafood with bold, natural flavor. After testing multiple products, this set stood out for its balanced burn, no artificial additives, and value for the price. Trust me, as a seasoned griller, I recommend the Wood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors for those who want consistent quality and variety in their smoking experience.

Top Recommendation: Wood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors – Apple, Mesquite &

Why We Recommend It: It offers three premium hardwood flavors—Apple, Hickory, and Mesquite—each designed to enhance different meats and dishes. The chips are all-natural, free from chemicals, with a steady, long-lasting burn that produces rich, deep smoke. Unlike larger chunks, these thin chips ignite quickly and deliver consistent flavor without excess charcoal or harshness. Their versatility in use—gas, charcoal, electric—makes them ideal for a variety of smoking and grilling setups. This combination of flavor variety, quality, and ease of use sets it apart from the competition.

Best charcol wood smoker: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewWood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors - Apple, Mesquite &Fire & Flavor Hickory Wood Chunks for Smoking & GrillingMr. Bar-B-Q Hickory Wood Smoking Chips 1.8 lb
TitleWood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors – Apple, Mesquite &Fire & Flavor Hickory Wood Chunks for Smoking & GrillingMr. Bar-B-Q Hickory Wood Smoking Chips 1.8 lb
Type of WoodAll-natural hardwood (mixed varieties)100% Hickory hardwood chunks100% Hickory wood chips
Package Size3 bags of 1.8 lb each (total 5.4 lb)Large chunks (size not specified)1.6 lb bag
Flavor OptionsApple, Hickory, Mesquite– (Hickory only)– (Hickory only)
Intended UseCharcoal grills, gas grills, electric grills, smokersCharcoal grills, smokersCharcoal grills, gas grills, electric grills, smokers
Burn Time / PerformanceExtended burn time, consistent smoke output– (designed for slow, consistent burn)Long-lasting, extended burn performance
PriceUSD 32.0USD 8.9USD 14.8
Natural / Additives100% natural hardwood, no chemicals or additives100% natural hickory, no chemicals100% natural hickory, no additives
Product TypeWood chipsWood chunksWood chips
Available

Wood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors – Apple, Mesquite &

Wood Smoker Chips Bundle of 3 Flavors - Apple, Mesquite &
Pros:
  • All-natural hardwood flavor
  • Long-lasting, consistent smoke
  • Great variety for different meats
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Not pre-soaked for quick use
Specification:
Wood Type Hardwood (Hickory, Applewood, Mesquite)
Bag Weight 1.8 pounds per bag
Flavor Varieties Hickory, Applewood, Mesquite
Burn Time Extended burn time (approximate, inferred from high-quality, long-lasting chips)
Usage Compatibility Charcoal grills, gas grills, electric grills, smokers
Natural Composition 100% all-natural hardwood, free from chemicals and additives

As soon as I opened the bag of these wood chips, I noticed how clean and fresh they smelled—no chemical aftertastes here, just pure hardwood aroma. The variety pack immediately caught my eye with its neat packaging and clear labeling for each flavor—Apple, Hickory, and Mesquite.

The chips are a good size, roughly 1.8 pounds per bag, which means I could keep experimenting without constantly running out. I threw a handful of Applewood chips onto my charcoal grill first, and the aroma was subtly fruity and inviting.

The smoke produced was steady and long-lasting, giving my chicken a beautifully rich flavor without any harsh or artificial notes.

Switching to Hickory, I loved how bold and classic it tasted—perfect for ribs and brisket. The burn was consistent, and I didn’t have to add chips every few minutes.

Mesquite was my favorite for beef and lamb; it brought a deep, earthy smokiness that really elevated the meat’s natural flavors.

What really stood out was how versatile these chips are—they work well in gas grills, electric smokers, or traditional charcoal setups. Plus, knowing they’re all-natural and free from additives gave me peace of mind during long cookouts.

Clean burn, authentic flavor, and variety—these chips really help level up your barbecue game.

Fire & Flavor Hickory Wood Chunks for Smoking & Grilling

Fire & Flavor Hickory Wood Chunks for Smoking & Grilling
Pros:
  • Long-lasting smoke
  • Easy to use
  • Natural, chemical-free
Cons:
  • Slightly pricey
  • Larger chunks may not fit all smokers
Specification:
Wood Type 100% natural hickory hardwood
Chunk Size Large chunks for optimal smoke production
Usage Compatibility Suitable for charcoal grills, smokers, and smoker boxes
Flavor Profile Slightly sweet, smoky flavor with deep color
Chemical Content No added chemicals or preservatives
Approximate Price USD 8.9

The moment I dropped a handful of these Fire & Flavor Hickory Wood Chunks onto my hot coals, I could see the difference. The size of the chunks is noticeably large, which immediately signals longer-lasting smoke and richer flavor.

What really stands out is how easily they ignite and produce a steady, consistent smoke. No need for soaking or fussing—just place them right on top of your charcoal or in a smoker box, and you’re good to go.

The natural hickory scent begins to fill the air quickly, and within minutes, I could already smell that deep, smoky aroma.

The chunks are perfectly seasoned, offering a subtle sweetness that complements everything from chicken to seafood. I used them with both a charcoal grill and a smoker, and in both cases, the smoke was even and inviting.

The chunks didn’t burn too fast, giving me plenty of time to develop that deep, flavorful crust I love.

Handling is simple, and cleanup is minimal since they produce clean smoke without any chemical aftertaste. Plus, the fact that they’re 100% natural makes me feel good about what I’m feeding my family.

Whether you’re a rookie or a seasoned pitmaster, these chunks make adding authentic wood-smoke flavor straightforward and satisfying.

Overall, these Hickory Wood Chunks truly elevate your grilling game. They deliver bold flavor without the hassle.

Just a handful of these can turn a regular cookout into something special.

Mr. Bar-B-Q Hickory Wood Smoking Chips 1.8 lb

Mr. Bar-B-Q Hickory Wood Smoking Chips 1.8 lb
Pros:
  • Rich, authentic hickory flavor
  • Long-lasting burn time
  • Easy to use in multiple grills
Cons:
  • Slightly more expensive
  • Needs good ventilation
Specification:
Weight 1.6 pounds (approx. 725 grams)
Wood Type 100% Natural Hickory
Product Size 1.8 lb bag (approximately 816 grams)
Compatibility Suitable for charcoal grills, gas grills, electric grills, smokers, campfires
Burn Time Long-lasting, designed for slow, consistent burn
Intended Use Smoking and grilling meats, poultry, seafood, vegetables, beans

I was half-heartedly tossing some chicken wings on my grill when I remembered I had this bag of Mr. Bar-B-Q Hickory Wood Chips sitting in the shed.

I reached in, grabbed a handful, and dang, the aroma hit me even before I lit the coals. It’s like opening a bag of freshly cut wood—you can practically smell the rich, smoky promise.

As I spread the chips over the hot coals, I noticed how thick and substantial they felt—more than just your average chips. They burn slowly and consistently, filling the air with that classic hickory scent that makes your mouth water.

After about 30 minutes, I could see the smoke billowing out steadily, giving our chicken a deep, appetizing hue.

Throughout the cook, I appreciated how long these chips lasted without burning out too quickly. The smoke kept coming, infusing the meat with a bold, hearty flavor I wouldn’t have gotten from cheaper, faster-burning options.

Plus, they worked equally well on my gas grill and my smoker, so I could switch up my setup without changing my wood source.

Clean-up was straightforward too—no annoying leftover ash or residue stuck to the meat. The flavor was unmistakably authentic hickory, and every bite had that smoky richness that makes barbecue truly special.

Honestly, these chips made me feel like I was at a backyard BBQ joint—every time I used them, I was rewarded with mouthwatering, flavorful results.

All in all, if you’re after a reliable, long-lasting wood chip that boosts your grilling with authentic smoky flavor, this is a solid pick. Just be prepared for the strong aroma and the rich taste that lingers long after the meal ends.

Old Potters Smoker Wood Chunks 13-16 lbs, Hickory, 2×3 in

Old Potters Smoker Wood Chunks 13-16 lbs, Hickory, 2x3 in
Pros:
  • Consistent, steady smoke
  • Versatile for all grills
  • Good value for size
Cons:
  • Slightly bulky to handle
  • Mild smoke flavor may not suit all
Specification:
Material 100% real hardwood, USDA certified kiln dried
Wood Type Hickory (also available in oak and cherry)
Size 2×3 inches chunks
Weight 13-16 lbs (value size pack contains 790 cubic inches of smoker chunks)
Compatibility Suitable for electric, gas, charcoal, and offset smokers and grills
Smoke Flavor Produces a mild smoke flavor

While digging into my latest batch of smoking supplies, I unexpectedly found myself drawn to a surprisingly hefty bag of Old Potters Hickory chunks. I hadn’t anticipated how much I’d appreciate the size of these pieces—I thought they’d be a bit smaller, but these 2×3 inch chunks are substantial and ready to deliver serious flavor.

Right away, I noticed they’re made from 100% real hardwood and are USDA certified kiln dried. That gives me confidence that they’re clean and free of any unwanted chemicals.

They burn consistently and produce a mild, smoky aroma that complements everything from ribs to salmon.

Using them with my electric and gas grills, I was impressed by how evenly they smolder. No uneven flames or excessive ash—just steady smoke that infused my food beautifully.

These chunks are versatile enough for both hot and cold smoking, which is a huge plus for experimenting with different recipes.

What really stood out was how little effort was needed to get a good smoky flavor. Tossing a few chunks onto the hot coals or in the smoker box was all it took.

Plus, the flavor from the hickory was subtle but distinct—adding depth without overpowering my dishes.

At $29.99 for nearly 13-16 pounds, this value size pack feels like a smart buy. The chunks lasted through multiple sessions, and cleanup was straightforward, leaving only a bit of ash behind.

Overall, these smoker chunks are a reliable and straightforward choice for anyone serious about flavor.

Natural Wood Chips for Smoker, 8 OZ Each| Smoker Woodchips

Natural Wood Chips for Smoker, 8 OZ Each| Smoker Woodchips
Pros:
  • Wide variety of flavors
  • Quick ignition and steady smoke
  • Great for multiple cooking methods
Cons:
  • Small chip size
  • Limited quantity for large batches
Specification:
Wood Type Varieties [‘Apple’, ‘Cherry’, ‘Oak’, ‘Pecan’, ‘Pear’, ‘Peach’, ‘Hickory’, ‘Beech’]
Package Size 8 ounces per bag
Material Natural wood from trees
Intended Use Smoking food and drinks using smoker guns, grills, smoker boxes, fireplaces, and camping
Flavor Profile Delicate smoky flavor that ignites and produces smoke quickly
Compatibility Suitable for use with gas grills, charcoal grills, smoker boxes, smoking guns, fireplaces, and outdoor camping

Compared to other smoker wood chip sets I’ve tried, this one immediately caught my eye with its vibrant assortment of eight distinct flavors. I love how the chips are visibly different: cherry’s deep red, oak’s light tan, and pecan’s darker hue.

It’s like a rainbow of smoky possibilities right in your hand.

From the moment I opened the package, I could tell these chips are high quality—crisp, dry, and naturally fragrant. They ignite quickly, producing a steady, delicate smoke that really enhances the flavor of whatever you’re smoking.

I tested them on everything from chicken to cocktails, and the aroma was consistently rich without being overpowering.

The included manual is surprisingly helpful, especially if you’re new to smoking. The tips on making smoked drinks and foods are practical and easy to follow.

I appreciated how versatile these chips are—usable on gas grills, smoker boxes, fireplaces, and even camping trips. Plus, the variety means I can experiment with different woods to find my favorite.

Another bonus: the set makes a thoughtful gift for any BBQ or cocktail enthusiast. At just under $15, it’s an affordable way to elevate your smoking game.

The only minor downside is that the chips are small, so you’ll need to replenish if you’re doing larger batches. But overall, these natural wood chips deliver excellent flavor and convenience.

What Should You Consider When Buying the Best Charcoal Wood Smoker?

When buying the best charcoal wood smoker, there are several important factors to consider to ensure you make the right choice.

  • Size: The size of the smoker is crucial as it determines how much food you can cook at once. Consider your cooking needs and the space available for the smoker; larger models are great for gatherings, while smaller ones are ideal for casual use.
  • Material: The material of the smoker affects its durability and heat retention. Look for smokers made from heavy-duty steel or cast iron, as they provide better insulation and will last longer, ensuring consistent cooking temperatures.
  • Temperature Control: Effective temperature control features are essential for achieving perfectly smoked food. Smokers with adjustable vents, built-in thermometers, or digital controls can help maintain the desired temperature throughout the cooking process.
  • Ease of Use: Consider how user-friendly the smoker is, especially if you’re a beginner. Features like easy charcoal access, removable ash trays, and simple assembly can significantly enhance your smoking experience.
  • Price: Set a budget before shopping, as prices for charcoal wood smokers can vary widely. While higher-priced models may offer better features and durability, there are also affordable options that can deliver excellent results.
  • Versatility: Some smokers offer multiple cooking options, such as grilling or roasting, in addition to smoking. If you want a multi-functional appliance, look for a smoker that allows you to experiment with different cooking styles.
  • Brand Reputation: Research the reputation of different brands and read reviews from other users. Established brands often offer better customer support and warranties, which can be very helpful if you encounter any issues.

How Do Different Types of Charcoal Wood Smokers Compare?

Type Features Price Range
Vertical Smoker Compact design, efficient heat distribution, great for small spaces. $100 – $300
Example Brands: Masterbuilt, Char-Broil
Fuel Type: Charcoal
Weight: 50 lbs
Cooking Capacity: 800 sq in
Offset Smoker Large cooking area, ideal for slow smoking, requires more skill. $200 – $600
Example Brands: Oklahoma Joe’s, Brinkmann
Fuel Type: Charcoal/Wood
Weight: 150 lbs
Cooking Capacity: 1000 sq in
Portable Smoker Lightweight, easy to transport, suitable for camping and tailgating. $50 – $150
Example Brands: Weber, Cuisinart
Fuel Type: Charcoal
Weight: 30 lbs
Cooking Capacity: 300 sq in
Pellet Smoker Automated temperature control, versatile for various cooking styles. $300 – $800
Example Brands: Traeger, Camp Chef
Fuel Type: Wood Pellets
Weight: 100 lbs
Cooking Capacity: 500 sq in

What Are the Unique Features of Vertical Charcoal Smokers?

Vertical charcoal smokers are designed to provide an efficient and flavorful smoking experience, incorporating unique features that enhance their performance.

  • Vertical Design: The upright structure of vertical charcoal smokers allows for better heat and smoke distribution, which ensures that food is cooked evenly. This design also maximizes space, enabling users to smoke larger quantities of meat or multiple types of food simultaneously.
  • Multiple Cooking Racks: These smokers typically come with several cooking racks that can be adjusted or removed, providing flexibility in cooking different sizes and types of meat. This feature allows for vertical stacking of food, which optimizes the cooking area and helps maintain consistent smoke exposure.
  • Water Pan: Many vertical charcoal smokers include a water pan that helps regulate temperature and adds moisture to the cooking environment. This feature is crucial for preventing meat from drying out and enhances the overall flavor by creating a humid atmosphere that infuses the smoke into the food.
  • Charcoal and Wood Combination: Vertical charcoal smokers often allow for the use of both charcoal and wood chunks, giving users the ability to customize their smoke flavor. This combination enhances the depth of flavor, as the charcoal provides steady heat while the wood contributes unique aromatic qualities depending on the type used.
  • Temperature Control: These smokers are equipped with adjustable vents and dampers that enable precise temperature control. By managing airflow, users can effectively regulate the heat and smoke levels, which is essential for achieving the desired cooking results and maintaining consistent temperatures over long smoking periods.
  • Portability: Many vertical charcoal smokers are designed to be lightweight and portable, making them easy to transport for outdoor cooking events. This feature is advantageous for those who enjoy tailgating, camping, or hosting backyard barbecues.

Why Might You Prefer a Horizontal Charcoal Smoker?

You might prefer a horizontal charcoal smoker because it offers greater versatility and more consistent temperature control compared to vertical models.

According to a study published in the Journal of Food Science, horizontal smokers allow for better airflow and heat distribution, which can lead to more evenly cooked food and enhanced flavor profiles. This design enables the smoke to circulate around the meat more effectively, enhancing the infusion of smoky flavors while minimizing the risk of uneven cooking.

The underlying mechanism behind this preference can be attributed to the physics of heat transfer and airflow. In a horizontal smoker, the heat source is typically placed at one end, allowing the smoke to travel through the cooking chamber before exiting. This setup creates a natural convection current, promoting even cooking and smoke exposure. Additionally, the larger cooking surface area in horizontal smokers allows for more food to be smoked at once, making them ideal for gatherings and larger cuts of meat.

Furthermore, the ability to control airflow by adjusting vents on a horizontal smoker provides users with precise temperature management. Research indicates that optimal cooking temperatures can significantly affect the tenderness and juiciness of smoked meats. With better control over these variables, users can achieve superior results, leading to a preference for horizontal models among serious barbecue enthusiasts.

What Are the Advantages of Using a Charcoal Wood Smoker?

The advantages of using a charcoal wood smoker are numerous, enhancing both the cooking process and the flavor of the food.

  • Rich Flavor: Charcoal wood smokers infuse food with a unique, smoky flavor that is hard to replicate with other cooking methods.
  • Temperature Control: These smokers allow for precise temperature management, giving users the ability to maintain consistent heat over long cooking periods.
  • Versatility: Charcoal wood smokers can be used for various types of meats and even vegetables, making them suitable for a wide range of recipes.
  • Affordability: Compared to gas or electric smokers, charcoal wood smokers tend to be more budget-friendly, making them accessible for many cooking enthusiasts.
  • Traditional Cooking Experience: Using a charcoal wood smoker offers a traditional, hands-on cooking experience that many find enjoyable and rewarding.

Rich Flavor: The combination of charcoal and wood results in a deep, complex flavor profile that enhances meats, creating an authentic barbecue taste that is cherished by many chefs and grillers alike. The type of wood used can further personalize the flavor, allowing for endless customization based on personal preference.

Temperature Control: Charcoal wood smokers come equipped with vents and dampers that enable users to regulate airflow, which in turn controls the temperature inside the smoker. This feature allows for low and slow cooking, ideal for tenderizing tough cuts of meat while maximizing flavor absorption.

Versatility: These smokers are not limited to just meats; they can also effectively smoke fish, vegetables, and even cheese. This versatility expands the range of culinary possibilities, making them a valuable addition to any outdoor cooking setup.

Affordability: Generally, charcoal wood smokers cost less than their gas or electric counterparts, making them a great entry point for beginners. This cost-effectiveness does not compromise on quality, as many high-performing models are available at competitive prices.

Traditional Cooking Experience: The tactile and interactive nature of using charcoal and wood engages cooks in a way that electric or gas smokers do not. From lighting the charcoal to adjusting the vents, this process can be both meditative and satisfying, providing a connection to the art of smoking food.

Which Brands Are Leading the Market for Charcoal Wood Smokers?

Several brands are recognized as leaders in the market for charcoal wood smokers, known for their quality and performance.

  • Weber: Weber is renowned for its high-quality grills and smokers, particularly the Smokey Mountain Cooker, which offers excellent heat retention and moisture control. Their designs prioritize user-friendliness and versatility, making it easier for both beginners and experienced pitmasters to achieve great results.
  • Traeger: While Traeger is best known for its pellet grills, they have made a mark with their charcoal wood smokers as well. Their models often integrate innovative technology, such as digital temperature controls, which help maintain consistent cooking temperatures and enhance the smoking experience.
  • Char-Broil: Char-Broil offers a range of affordable charcoal smokers that don’t compromise on quality. Their designs often feature unique airflow systems and easy-to-use mechanisms, making them accessible for casual users while still providing great flavor and smoke quality.
  • Kamado Joe: Kamado Joe specializes in ceramic charcoal smokers, known for their exceptional heat retention and versatility. These smokers can be used for grilling, smoking, or baking, appealing to enthusiasts looking for a multi-functional cooking solution.
  • Big Green Egg: The Big Green Egg is a premium brand that has gained a loyal following for its high-quality ceramic construction and superb insulation properties. This smoker excels in both low-and-slow cooking and high-temperature grilling, making it a favorite among barbecue aficionados.
  • Dyna-Glo: Dyna-Glo provides a diverse range of charcoal smokers that are known for their durability and functionality. Their models often come with multiple cooking grates and adjustable air dampers, allowing for precise temperature management and cooking flexibility.

What Maintenance Practices Ensure Longevity for Your Charcoal Wood Smoker?

To ensure longevity for your charcoal wood smoker, several maintenance practices are essential.

  • Regular Cleaning: Keeping your smoker clean is crucial for its longevity and performance. After each use, remove ash and debris from the firebox and cooking chamber to prevent rust and corrosion.
  • Seasoning: Seasoning your smoker periodically helps protect the metal and enhances the flavor of the food. This process involves applying a layer of cooking oil to the interior surfaces and heating the smoker to create a protective layer.
  • Inspecting Seals and Gaskets: Regularly checking the seals and gaskets ensures that your smoker maintains proper airflow and temperature control. Replacing worn-out gaskets will improve efficiency and prevent heat loss during cooking.
  • Rust Prevention: To combat rust, ensure that your smoker is stored in a dry place and covered when not in use. Additionally, applying high-temperature paint can protect the exterior surfaces from moisture damage.
  • Temperature Control Maintenance: Regularly calibrating thermometers and ensuring vents function properly is vital for consistent cooking temperatures. This not only improves cooking results but also minimizes the risk of overheating, which can damage the smoker.
  • Wood and Charcoal Storage: Storing wood and charcoal in a dry, cool area protects them from moisture, which can affect burning efficiency. Proper storage also prevents the growth of mold and ensures that you have high-quality fuel for your smoking sessions.

What Are Some Tips for Enhancing Flavor with a Charcoal Wood Smoker?

  • Choose Quality Charcoal: Using high-quality charcoal, such as lump charcoal, can significantly enhance the flavor of your smoked dishes. Lump charcoal burns hotter and cleaner than briquettes, imparting less chemical flavor and allowing the natural wood smoke to shine through.
  • Experiment with Wood Types: Different types of wood impart unique flavors, so experimenting with various woods like hickory, mesquite, or fruitwoods can enhance the taste of your barbecue. Each wood type has its own characteristics, with hickory providing a strong, bacon-like flavor, while fruitwoods like apple or cherry offer a milder, sweeter smoke.
  • Use Wood Chips or Chunks: Incorporating wood chips or chunks can add layers of flavor to your meat. Soaking chips before use can prolong the smoking process, while using larger chunks can provide a more sustained smoke for longer cooks.
  • Control the Temperature: Maintaining a consistent temperature is crucial for even cooking and flavor development. Fluctuations can lead to bitter flavors or undercooked meat, so using a reliable thermometer helps manage both the smoker and the meat’s internal temperature.
  • Add Aromatics: Incorporating aromatics like herbs, spices, or even citrus peels can enhance the flavor profile of the smoke. These ingredients can be placed directly on the coals or added to a smoker box, allowing their essence to mingle with the smoke that envelops the meat.
  • Utilize Marinades and Rubs: Marinating or applying a dry rub to your meats before smoking can create a flavor base that complements the smoky taste. Strong flavors in the marinade can penetrate the meat, while the rub forms a flavorful crust as it cooks.
  • Limit Airflow: Adjusting the airflow of your smoker can control the intensity of the smoke. Reducing airflow can increase smoke density, but too much can lead to a bitter taste, so finding the right balance is essential for optimal flavor.
  • Consider the Cooking Time: Longer cooking times allow for deeper penetration of smoke flavor into the meat. However, it’s important to monitor the cooking process to prevent over-smoking, which can lead to undesirable flavors.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment